Vanguard, validity and viability of societal accountability conceived by Guillermo O'Donnell.
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.35487/rius.v12i42.2018.390Keywords:
Accountability, symbolic capital, traditional mass media, social networks.Abstract
From the collective work Controlling politics. Citizens and the media in the new Latin American democracies (2002), where Guillermo O'Donnell debates the con- cept of accountability with Peruzzotti, Smulovitz and Przeworski, rescues the research agenda proposed by O'Donnell. The examination aims to make explicit the typology of accountability with its respective criteria; characterize evaluate their possible implementation with the contributions of the current digital age. The methodology for the first three objectives follows the conceptual analysis developed by O'Donnell and other studies on his thoughts. For the last objective, a prospec- tive is made where cybernetic instruments can work in favor of societal accountability.
Downloads
References
AGUIRRE, JORGE, LA DEMOCRACIA LÍQUIDA. LOS NUEVOS MODELOS POLÍTICOS EN LA ERA DI- GITAL, BARCELONA, UOC, 2016.
ARENDT, HANNAH, ENTRE EL PASADO Y EL FUTURO, BARCELONA, PENÍNSULA, 1996. BARBER, BENJAMÍN, “¿HASTA QUÉ PUNTO SON DEMOCRÁTICAS LAS NUEVAS TECNOLOGÍAS DE
TELECOMUNICACIÓN?”, IDP REVISTA DE INTERNET, DERECHO Y POLÍTICA, NÚM. 3. BERG-SCHLOSSER, DICK, “THE QUALITY OF DEMOCRACIES IN EUROPE AS MEASURED BY CURRENT
INDICATORS OF DEMOCRATIZATION AND GOOD GOVERNANCE”, JOURNAL OF COMMU-
NIST STUDIES AND TRANSITION POLITICS, VOL. 20, NÚM. 1. CARPINTERO, ENRIQUE, “EL CONCEPTO DE ‘POSVERDAD’: UNA NUEVA MENTIRA”, REVISTA TOPÍA.
[CONSULTA: 19 DE MAYO, 2017]. DISPONIBLE EN: HTTPS://WWW.TOPIA.COM.AR/AR-
TICULOS/CONCEPTO-POSVERDAD-UNA-NUEVA-MENTIRA CASTELLS, MANUEL, LA GALAXIA INTERNET, ESPAÑA, PLAZA Y JANÉS, 2001. COLLINGWOOD, VIVIEN, GOOD GOVERNANCE AND THE WORLD BANK, REINO UNIDO, UNIVERSITY OF OXFORD, 2003. DAHL, ROBERT, LA POLIARQUÍA. PARTICIPACIÓN Y OPOSICIÓN, MADRID, TECNOS, 1989. ELGUETA, RAÚL, “RESENCIÓN DE PERUZZOTTI, ENRIQUE Y CATALINA SMULOVITZ (EDS.). 2002.
CONTROLANDO LA POLÍTICA: CIUDADANOS Y MEDIOS EN LAS NUEVAS DEMOCRACIAS. BUENOS AIRES: EDITORIAL TEMAS, 325 PP.”, REVISTA DE CIENCIA POLÍTICA, VOL. 23, NÚM. 2.
FOUCAULT, MICHEL, OBRAS ESENCIALES, VOL. II, ESTRATEGIAS DE PODER, BARCELONA, PAIDÓS, 1999.
GARCÍA GUAL, CARLOS, “LA GRECIA ANTIGUA”, EN FERNANDO VALLESPÍN (ED.), HISTORIA DE LA TEORÍA POLÍTICA, I, MADRID, ALIANZA, 1990.
HABERMAS, JURGEN, HISTORIA Y CRÍTICA DE LA OPINIÓN PÚBLICA, BARCELONA, EDICIONES G. GILI, 2007.
HELD, DAVID, MODELOS DE DEMOCRACIA, MADRID, ALIANZA, 1991. HIRSCHMANN, ALBERT, EXIT, VOICE AND LOYALTY. RESPONSES TO DECLINE IN FIRMS, ORGANI-
ZATIONS, AND STATES, CAMBRIDGE, HARVARD UNIVERSITY PRESS, 1970. HOWARD, PHILIP, “SOCIAL MEDIA, CIVIC ENGAGEMENT, AND THE SLACTIVISM HYPOTHESIS: LES- SONS FROM MEXICO’S ‘EL BRONCO’”, JOURNAL OF INTERNATIONAL AFFAIRS, VOL. 70,
NÚM. 1. HOWARD, PHILIP, “PARTICIPATION, CIVICS AND YOUR NEXT COFFEE MAKER”, POLICY AND INTER-
NET, VOL. 6, NÚM. 2. KAUFMANN, DANIEL, KRAAY, AART, Y MASTRUZZI, MASSIMO, “THE WORLDWIDE GOVERNANCE
INDICATORS: METHODOLOGY AND ANALYTICAL ISSUES”, 2010 [CONSULTA: 24 DE ABRIL,
. DISPONIBLE EN: HTTP://INFO.WORLDBANK.ORG/ LIDÉN, GUSTAV, “IS E-DEMOCRACY MORE THAN DEMOCRATIC? —AN EXAMINATION OF THE IM-
PLEMENTATION OF SOCIALLY SUSTAINABLE VALUES IN E-DEMOCRATIC PROCESSES”, EJEG,
VOL. 10, NÚM. 1. MACHIAVELLI, NICCOLÒ, DE PRINCIPATIBUS, MÉXICO, TRILLAS, 1999. MALENA, CARMEN, FORSTER, REINER, Y SINGH, JAMEJAY, “SOCIAL ACCOUNTABILITY. AN INTRO-
DUCTION TO THE CONCEPT AND EMERGING PRACTICE”, WORLD BANK, SOCIAL DEVELO-
PMENT PAPERS, NÚM. 76. MARAVALL, JOSÉ MARÍA, ACCOUNTABILITY AND THE SURVIVAL OF GOVERNMENTS, MADRID, CEN-
TRO DE ESTUDIOS AVANZADOS EN CIENCIAS SOCIALES, 2005. MORLINO, LEONARDO, “WHAT IS ‘GOOD’ DEMOCRACY?”, DEMOCRATIZATION, VOL. 11, NÚM. 5. MOROZOV, EVEGNY, “RESPONSE TO PHILIP N. HOWARD’S REVIEW OF THE NET DELUSION: THE
DARK SIDE OF INTERNET FREEDOM”, PERSPECTIVES ON POLITICS, VOL. 9, NÚM. 4. MOROZOV, EVEGNY, “FROM SLACKTIVISM TO ACTIVISM”, NET EFFECT BLOG. [CONSULTA: 28 DE NOVIEMBRE, 2017]. DISPONIBLE EN: HTTP://NETEFFECT.FOREIGNPOLICY.COM/
POSTS/2009/09/05/FROM_SLACKTIVISM_TO_ACTIVISM NATERA, ANTONIO, “NUEVAS ESTRUCTURAS Y REDES DE GOBERNANZA”, REVISTA MEXICANA DE
SOCIOLOGÍA, VOL. 67, NÚM. 4. O’DONNELL, GUILLERMO, “RENDICIÓN DE CUENTAS HORIZONTAL Y NUEVAS POLIARQUÍAS”, NUE-
VA SOCIEDAD, NÚM. 152. O’DONNELL, GUILLERMO, “ACCOUNTABILITY HORIZONTAL: LA INSTITUCIONALIZACIÓN LEGAL DE LA
DESCONFIANZA POLÍTICA”, POSTDATA, REVISTA DE REFLEXIÓN Y ANÁLISIS POLÍTICO,
NÚM. 7. O’DONNELL, GUILLERMO, DISONANCIAS: CRÍTICAS DEMOCRÁTICAS A LA DEMOCRACIA. BUENOS AIRES, PROMETEO, 2007. PANIAGUA, ABRAHAM, JOSÉ BORUNDA E IGNACIO CAMARGO, “TRANSPARENCIA, PARTICIPACIÓN
CIUDADANA Y GOBIERNO ELECTRÓNICO: EL CASO DEL GOBIERNO LOCAL DE CIUDAD
JUÁREZ, MÉXICO”, SOCIEDADE E CULTURA, AÑO 15, NÚM. 1. PARTIDO COMUNISTA OBRERO ESPAÑOL, 2013, ISLANDIA: RADIOGRAFÍA DE UNA REVOLUCIÓN
«CIUDADANA». [CONSULTA: 19 DE MAYO, 2017]. DISPONIBLE EN: HTTP://WWW. PCOE.NET/ACTUALIDAD1/ACTUALIDAD-INTERNACIONAL/444-ISLANDIA-RADIOGRA- FIA-DE-UNA-REVOLUCION-CIUDADANA
PASQUINO, GIANFRANCO, NUEVO CURSO DE CIENCIA POLÍTICA, MÉXICO, FONDO DE CULTURA ECONÓMICA, 2011.
PEIXOTO, TIAGO, “PRESUPUESTOS PARTICIPATIVOS MÁS TECNOLOGÍA. LA FÓRMULA PERFECTA PARA LA INCLUSIÓN Y LA PARTICIPACIÓN CIUDADANA”, PERSPECTIVA DOSSIER, VOL. 2. [CONSULTA: 12 DE ENERO, 2015]. DISPONIBLE EN: HTTP://WWW.REVISTAPERSPECTIVA. COM/DOSSIER-CONTENIDO/2/PRESUPUESTO-PARTICIPATIVO-TECNOLOGIA-LA-FORMU- LA-PERFECTA-PARA-LA-INCLUSIONY-LA-PARTICIPACION-CIUDADANA
PERUZZOTTI, ENRIQUE Y SMULOVITZ, CATALINA, CONTROLANDO LA POLÍTICA. CIUDADANOS Y ME- DIOS EN LAS NUEVAS DEMOCRACIAS LATINOAMERICANAS, BUENOS AIRES, EDITORIAL TEMAS, 2002.
PLATÓN, DIÁLOGOS, IV. REPÚBLICA, MADRID, GREDOS, 2008. REINHGOLD, HOWARD, THE VIRTUAL COMMUNITY: HOMESTEADING ON THE ELECTRONIC FRONTIER,
ESTADOS UNIDOS, HARPER PERENNIAL PAPERBACK, 1993. SALAS, JAVIER, “LA GRAN CIZAÑA DE LOS ‘BOTS’ DE INTERNET”, EL PAÍS, AÑO 41, NÚM. 14749. SÁNCHEZ DE DIOS, MANUEL, “NUEVA PERSPECTIVA DE LA RESPONSABILIDAD POLÍTICA: LA ‘TEORÍA
DE LA AGENCIA’”, REVISTA DE LAS CORTES GENERALES, NÚM. 67. SHUGART, MATTHES, MORENO, ERIKA Y CRISP, BRIAN, “THE ACCOUNTABILITY DEFICIT IN LATIN AMERICA” PREPARED FOR THE CONFERENCE ON “INSTITUTIONS, ACCOUNTABILITY, AND
DEMOCRATIC GOVERNANCE IN LATIN AMERICA”, KELLOGG INSTITUTE FOR INTERNATIO- NAL STUDIES, UNIVERSITY OF NOTRE DAME, NOTRE DAME, INDIANA, MAY 8–9, 2000. [CONSULTA: 7 DE AGOSTO, 2017]. DISPONIBLE EN: HTTPS://WWW3.ND.EDU/~KELLO- GG/FACULTY/RESEARCH/PDFS/SHUGART.PDF
SMULOVITZ, CATALINA Y PERUZZOTTI, ENRIQUE, “SOCIETAL ACCOUNTABILITY IN LATIN AMERICA”, JOURNAL OF DEMOCRACY, VOL. 11, NÚM. 4.
TILLY, CHARLES, Y WOOD, LESLEY, SOCIAL MOVEMENTS, 1768-2012, BOULDER, PARADIGM, 2013.
VAN DIJK, JAN, “MODELS OF DEMOCRACY AND CONCEPTS OF COMMUNICATION”, K. HACKER AND JAN VAN DIJK (EDS.), DIGITAL DEMOCRACY. ISSUES OF THEORY AND PRACTICE, LONDRES, THOUSAND OAKS CA, NUEVA DELHI, SAGE, 2000.
WORLD BANK, “EMPOWERING PEOPLE BY TRANSFORMING INSTITUTIONS: SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT IN WORLD BANK OPERATIONS”, 2005. [CONSULTA: 4 DE MAYO, 2017] DISPONIBLE EN: HTTP://DOCUMENTS.WORLDBANK.ORG/CURATED/EN/563751468780547056/EMPOWERING-PEOPLE-BY-TRANSFORMING-INSTITUTIONS-SOCIAL-DEVELOP-
MENT-IN-WORLD-BANK-OPERATIONS WORLD BANK, “SOCIAL ACCOUNTABILITY AND DEMAND FOR GOOD GOVERNANCE, 2013”, WORLD
BANK. [CONSULTA: 5 DE MAYO, 2017]. DISPONIBLE EN: HTTP://WWW.WORLDBANK.
ORG/EN/TOPIC/SOCIALDEVELOPMENT/BRIEF/SOCIAL-ACCOUNTABILITY ZAFRA, JOSÉ, “RESPONSABILIDAD POLÍTICA DEL GOBIERNO: CUESTIONES FUNDAMENTALES”, EN M. RAMÍREZ (ED.), EL CONTROL PARLAMENTARIO EN LAS DEMOCRACIAS PLURALISTAS,
BARCELONA, LABOR, 1978.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Revista IUS, published by the Legal Sciences Institute of Puebla A.C., is distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International (CC BY-NC 4.0) license.
We authorize collaborators to upload a copy of their published work on their personal websites or any Open Access repository, provided that Revista IUS is specifically cited as the original source, indicating the year and issue of the respective example and adding the link to the webpage on which this publication can be freely consulted in toto and without charge: http://www.revistaius.com
Readers are free to:
Share, copy and redistribute the material via any medium or format.
The licensor cannot revoke these freedoms as long as you follow the license terms.
Under the following terms:
Attribution: You must give appropriate credit, provide a link to the license, and indicate if changes were made.
You may do so in any reasonable manner, but not in any way that suggests the licensor endorses you or your use.
NonCommercial – You may not use the material for commercial purposes.
If you remix, transform or build upon the licensed material, its distribution is not permitted.
Charges for managing articles: Revista IUS will not charge for receiving, processing or publishing articles (Article Processing Charge, or APC) submitted by authors.
